What drives recruiter and head hunter pricing
Contingency recruiting (paying only upon successful placement) typically charges 8.33%-16.67% of the hired candidate's annual salary, while retained search (paid upfront regardless of outcome, typically used for senior or specialized roles) charges a similar or higher percentage but with payment structured across the search process rather than only on success.
Rates can vary based on seniority of the role - executive and C-suite search typically commands fees at the higher end of the range, reflecting the more extensive, discreet search process these placements usually require. If you want a sense of typical pricing first, our recruiters & head hunters cost breakdown covers what drives the numbers.
Contingency vs retained search: a genuine strategic choice
Contingency search works well for roles with a reasonably available talent pool, since multiple recruiters can work the same role simultaneously with no upfront risk to you. Retained search suits senior, highly specialized, or confidential roles where a dedicated, focused search effort and recruiter commitment matters more than casting the widest possible net. If you're also comparing blog writing services providers, those listings work the same way on Leadzo.
Take the next step
Get quotes from verified recruitersWhy industry specialization matters significantly
A recruiter with deep experience in your specific industry or function typically has existing relationships with relevant passive candidates (people not actively job-searching but open to the right opportunity) and better understands the nuances of what makes a strong fit beyond just matching a job description to a resume.
A specialized recruiter can also often provide useful market insight - realistic salary benchmarking, likely time-to-fill expectations, and candidate availability trends - that helps you set realistic expectations for the search from the outset. You can compare quotes from verified recruiters & head hunters professionals directly on Leadzo once you know what to ask for.
What a good recruiting engagement should include
A thorough recruiter should take time to genuinely understand your company culture, team dynamics, and the specific challenges of the role beyond a generic job description, and should provide a reasonable shortlist of pre-screened candidates rather than simply forwarding a high volume of unfiltered resumes.
It's also worth asking how the recruiter sources passive candidates specifically, since this reveals whether they're relying purely on job board postings (which active candidates would find themselves) or genuinely reaching people not actively searching but open to the right opportunity.
Replacement guarantees deserve clarification
Many recruiters offer a replacement guarantee - if a placed candidate leaves within a specified period (commonly 90 days to 6 months), they'll conduct a replacement search at no additional fee. Confirm this policy clearly before engaging, since it provides meaningful protection if a placement doesn't work out as expected.
It's worth getting this guarantee in writing as part of the engagement terms rather than relying on a verbal assurance, since disputes about replacement obligations are more easily resolved when the original terms were clearly documented. If a term like "Freelancer vs Agency Pricing" comes up while you're comparing quotes, see our glossary definition for exactly what it means.
Communication cadence during an active search
Agree upfront on how often you'll receive updates during an active search - weekly check-ins are common, especially for retained search engagements, so you have visibility into candidate pipeline progress rather than radio silence until a shortlist is finally presented.
It's also worth discussing how the recruiter handles candidate feedback after interviews on your end, since prompt, honest feedback helps them refine the search if initial candidates aren't quite the right fit. A related category worth comparing is CV writing, which follows a similar hiring process.
Red flags worth taking seriously
If you're also comparing CV writing providers, those listings work the same way on Leadzo.
- Forwarding a high volume of unfiltered, poorly-matched resumes rather than a curated shortlist
- No replacement guarantee offered for placements that don't work out
- Limited understanding of your company culture or the role's specific requirements
- Pressure to make a hiring decision quickly without adequate time for your own evaluation process
Retained versus contingency search, and what that means for you
Recruiters typically work on either a contingency basis (paid only if they successfully place a candidate, usually a percentage of first-year salary) or a retained basis (paid an upfront fee for a dedicated, prioritized search, common for senior or specialized roles) - and the right model depends on how urgent and specialized the role is. Contingency recruiters often work multiple open roles simultaneously, which can mean less dedicated focus on any single search compared to a retained arrangement.
Ask about the recruiter's specific track record in your industry and role level, their typical time-to-fill, and how they source candidates - a strong network in your specific niche matters more than general recruiting volume. Clarify the guarantee period (how long after placement they'll re-search for free if the hire doesn't work out), since this varies and is worth negotiating upfront.
Ask how candidates are initially screened before being presented to you, since a recruiter who sends a high volume of loosely-matched profiles is providing less real value than one doing genuine upfront filtering against your specific requirements. Clarify communication frequency and format during an active search, so you know what to expect in terms of updates while the search is underway. Many independent professionals in this space register as a small business through the government's Udyam (MSME) registration portal.
